|
| Discussion board for Peranmai Review (137 Messages) |
|
|
| Nithya 18 Feb 10, 12:38am |
| i think this is a very biased review.apparently the reviewer is one of those C rated viewer who prefers his tamil films with one kuthu song, amma sentiment, heroism and comedy tracks. or maybe he cnat take it that there is no hero heroine nonsense in this film. whatever it is,the reviewer has no taste. of course this film had its flaws, but what matters is they had a message that matters and i think htey have successfully put it across. |
|
|
| Prabha 27 Jan 10, 04:01pm |
| hi! guys u dont know that peranmai is a remake . but that's true. it is a russian movie remake. it was early in 1930s |
|
|
| Ratha 26 Jan 10, 02:39am |
Movie is good but not too good
the climax is sick |
|
|
| Marx 14 Jan 10, 04:28pm |
| ur review sucks ! peranmai is a must watch movie folks.... |
|
|
| Jeyachandran 10 Jan 10, 02:33pm |
"guys dont think this film was made brilliantly, it was remake from a russian movie ",
it was released early 1930-1940. The story revolves around 5 girls and one old man's war against british soldier's ( 16 members). this russian movie was already telecasted in makkal tv. our director's are copying the films from world movies. |
|
|
| Manivannan 30 Dec 09, 06:24pm |
This is the right flim for the society with good concept and action.I really want to thank and appreciate ravi and other five girls who have done a mind blowing performance.
I thing this flim will be boosting to achive my ambition. |
|
|
| Sathiya 18 Dec 09, 11:47am |
| Atleast we are getting know something new through this movie. We should appreciate these kind of movies while some other movies nowdays coming for heroism and other glamour heroines.. This is a stepping stone for Tamil cinema, not a block. Students should see these kind of movies to know that still some of the low caste people are trying to get education. |
|
|
| Mani 4 Dec 09, 05:32am |
| I watched the movie yesterday - I was so happy I was not in theater. What a childish treatment for a novel concept. Could not sit through at all. Very amateurish treatment. With so many people saying that this is a great movie blah blah.. It looks like they saw a different movie ...Or methinks - they are friends with the producer/director or what ever... Dont waste your time seeing this movie. Major waste. |
|
|
| Vandana 30 Nov 09, 11:57pm |
| Not sure if the author understood the movie correctly. It's an awesome movie taken in a very logical way. No nonsense movie. |
|
|
| Krishnakanth 30 Nov 09, 11:01am |
The greatest movie ever did in tamil cinema... lol...
i would suggest to give a nomination to oscar award... and jayam ravi will get the "best strippper award"....
rofl.... |
|
|
| Sanal Rasheed 27 Nov 09, 08:33pm |
| kalip |
|
|
| Jai 24 Nov 09, 03:04pm |
| Very, very good movie, i have seen this three times., after very long time. good |
|
|
| Nellai Mano 18 Nov 09, 03:10pm |
| come on, the reviewer obviously has a strong bias against the PERANMAI team. the movie, with all its flaws, is a path-breaking one in Tamil. Jayam Ravi, for once has put up a splendid performance. The characters of the college girls are excellently brought out. |
|
|
| Jovita 17 Nov 09, 09:41am |
| Movie is very good..Hats off to Jeyam Ravi and Jananathan... |
|
|
| Kannan 14 Nov 09, 10:12pm |
| kalip padam |
|
|
| Karthikeyan 12 Nov 09, 03:27pm |
| I forgot to mention some flaws which I noticed in this movie.One such scene is pug marks of leopard.Actually its not leopard,it is of bear.I wish director should not take it lightly when it comes for other race.I also didn't like the environment to be polluted with fireworks.In upcoming films if in wilderness then please make sure not to disturb the environment as the habitat species are already suffering a lot due to biotic pressure.Anyway I am very much happy that the movie is hit and one thing I wish to say ,despite heavy rain I took my parents last weekend to watch this movie in chennai.They are also glad sparing time for this WORTH TO WATCH MOVIE.I wish the entire team should reunite again to produce lot of worth movies like this with updates on user comments. |
|
|
| Naanjil Wala 12 Nov 09, 11:19am |
The film is really superb i really enjoyed the movie,Actually first i went to watch aadhavan , thank god the ticket is finished and counter is shut down I am very big fan of surya i did"nt watch the bcoz of bore review of movie
It is worth watch movie Please watch the movie especially the directors like perarasu , shakthi chidambaram and all masala movie movie makers And the great Dr.Vijay ,Bharath,Vishal |
|
|
| S.kumar 10 Nov 09, 01:07pm |
| Some of the people who posted their comments, are acting like too smart. Nobody is perfect in this world. We should appreciate the movies like this. Obviously PERANNMAI is a good movie. Every one should watch and support the movie like this. |
|
|
| Vais 10 Nov 09, 11:52am |
| very good movie i like it very much i love jayam ravi |
|
|
| Prabhu 9 Nov 09, 07:05am |
| Watchable film...and yes ofcourse it has flaws..nobody can name a PERFECT tamil film that has all tids and bits correct. anyone can write an essay of pitfalls of anymovie and even write a book if they watch in one angle..even with flaws it has some kind of attraction to watch and this is well evident that ppl have given good judgement from all corners. we should encourage this welcoming change in tamil cinema even if it is not a good start. |
|
|
| Mani 8 Nov 09, 02:02am |
| Nice film |
|
|
| Sathish 7 Nov 09, 08:23pm |
| It really stands out from the usual boring tamil cinema... Lets appreciate these kind of new efforts though its not upto the mark. |
|
|
| Krishnakanth 7 Nov 09, 01:17pm |
First i really liked jananadhan’s last two movie “Iyarkai” and “E”. That was really natural.It was not commercial.
BUT this movie Peranmai: Its a complete WARSHIT.If you are new to a wartime movie then this will look like the best one you had ever seen.
But the actual fact is it cannot even get into the class of wartime action movie.Jayam ravi has acted well, the gals have done their job.
The problem is with the director.He has to be more cautious while delivering a movie to a vast variety of audience.First, the movie is more of tamil race biased.They are lauching a satellite with a tamil name “pasumai puratchi”,its really a rare case in INDIA.They say
“tamizhar vinnaiyum aalalam”.We guys dont even have enough power to save the poor fisher mans who are being shot near srilanka.why the hell
they think tamil nadu has such great powers.Our Indian navy is incapable of even helping our tamil people.
I had been into an NCC camp and we have never used TAMIL commands to communicate.But i dont know if it was a pressure to the director to use TAMIL
words or he was really unaware.
There was a scene where we had to see Jayam Ravi’s backs on screen the way women used to do,and I can guarantee you that you never see a real men
show his ass on any screen but if you do, it will not be shaved. It will be hairy and hoary.
The hero is in charge of leading a team of 5 gals into the forest for training.I dont understand why he has to beg the gals.
YOU ARE A COMMANDER GODDAMN IT. You got to command the gals and lead them.And not sing songs on the way.
I am still not convinced that jayam ravi advices the gals to drive during the disaster and doesnot attempt to take the driver seat when it was an emergency.
I know the scipt was from a Russian Novel, the underneath concept was good. But the way it was told really funny.These five newly trained Amature
NCC’s fight against a group of 16 missionaries who are proffessional trained.And for your information they have just got the manual reload rifle in their
hands.
Ah i had to mention it. The fight of Jayam ravi. Does he thinks he is inside a vietnamese jungle so that he can perform a guerilla attack.And i really
wonder how four gals with no glooves or any hand gaurd can lower jayam ravi at a very high speed and pull him back at the same speed.
Does the director thinks tamil people dont even have common sense .A 2nd grade child would say the leafs of a tree will fall when shaked.
But the professional killer one among the villians dont realize that.
There was another shot where jeyam ravi will come out a tree with a cooling glass on his nose.The killer who has M60 in his hands will get afraid of
seeing UNARMED jeyam ravi and runs for his life. I cant even imaging how director think jeyam ravi will look like an alien or a predator to the enemies.
And i know gals talk more.But in this movie Jeyam ravi talks more than that.They have the worst communication code in War history “cuckoo” birds
humming.And jeyam ravi caves in and shy’s when gals ask him to humm like cuckoo.That scene i really vomitted.I had never seen a commander doing
that in any war movie in my life time.And this code was used very badly.When Jayam ravi humms in the middle of war, the gals get up from a very short
distance. I hope code is for people at far distance.This code was easily decoded by the villain.
Even a computer stimulation of this scenario would fail, with 5 NCC gals and their trainer(not even from Indian army) against 16 trained missionaries who can destory any satellite in any part of the world are incompetant in Tamil nadu.
And one more thing, does the director thinks we dont know any thing about weapons.Do you think a NCC student who cant even hold the gun pressed
against her shoulder can operate a 25kg “STINGER MISSILE”.The first gun fire was on a tape recorder.would you ever see something like that in a war
movie?.I had seen only bullets hitting human parts in a action movie.And the sadest part Nobody on Jeyam Ravi’s side was hit even by a single bullet.
Not even the makeup was disturbed. NO sweat on the gals face was visible.Jeyam ravi lifts a RAPID FIRE GUN like a paper gun and fires it like a
mosquito spray. Does he thinks he is rajinikanth. I personally hate the seen where the gals were shown as godess kali and the enemies run seeing it.
And the comedy in the movie was when the gals say “hey rocket thookudhu down arrow azhuthu”, do they think working on a rocket missile is as easy as
a video game? And is it only possible in tamil cinema to hack a locked code and a set timer with zero hacking knowledge.
Roland Kickinger was the only smart guy in the movie and dont ever say that jayam ravi had Good physic in that movie, he was looking like a INDIAN POW.
WITH ALL THESE DOES JANANADHAN THINKS HE HAS GIVEN ANOTHER HIT MOVIE? |
|
|
| Sundaram R M 6 Nov 09, 08:45pm |
I do not see tamil movies. I read in news paper that I has been shot in mundanturi Tiger resrve, I belong to Ravanasamudaram 12 KM from the temple. So I went to see the movie. It was the only best movie I saw for years, I love Patriotic movies. More than the Hero the girls acted in the movie has done the best job. All my wishs to all the 5 girls
|
|
|
| Vijay 4 Nov 09, 09:40pm |
didn expect this sought of acting frm ravi...
i expectd 1% but he showed 100% talnt in dis movie...
gud atempt...
gud leson for masala movie makers... |
|
|
| Tamil 4 Nov 09, 09:31pm |
| hey... alys tamil films give sme buildups... and people loves it... but, the fil is gud... |
|
|
| Sunil A Manalody 4 Nov 09, 08:47am |
| I am very disappointed with the review.. The movie is very good. |
|
|
| Rakesh D 4 Nov 09, 08:03am |
| I am,too disappointed with this review.Movie is really good.Not upto hollywood films,but Most of the shots in forest are world class.We should appreciate these kinds of movies in tamil,even if it had some logic breaking scenes.This is one of the fantastic acting ang getup of Ravi.I am expecting ravi will do these kind of movies in future. |
|
|
| Karthikeyan 3 Nov 09, 09:37pm |
| I wonder in the past why tamil movies were still rolling around with masala scripts.So I stopped watching tamil movies and focus only on hollywood their action is full of fireworks though. As I mentioned in other website,I truly admire about this movie.Here I soundly raise my voice " no stupid/crack dance between concrete walls,romance,punch dialogue and same action styles with nuisance background sound effect". It doesn't meant that despite some minor faults this movie should be ignored.Hope from negative comments,director will consider them as lesson and rectify it in next movies without disappointment,since 9/10 wish to promote this trend which is going to reflect/credit not only for tamil ,the whole india world wide.I never commented on any of tamil movies before,this is first time.Appreciate whole unit for their efforts and considering wilderness as main character. |
|
|
| Vinoth 3 Nov 09, 01:49pm |
| I am really worried about this review... I couldnt understand what made you to write this review. Majority of this movie has good things but you are really hunting for critics. Why are you asking how Jayam Ravi kill Roland in 30 secs? I think you are good to watch WWF and not movies like this. but here the director Jananathan have depicted with lots of emotions and patriotism. The cinematography has lots to speak but you simply said in a single line as extradinary i think this is not enough. Also the script has many Marxist and communist thought involved and this is really good to bring with a strong message. Please grow up..... I am not a fan of either Jayam Ravi or Dir Jananathan... I do agree the movie has some flaws and draw back.. in fact every movie willl have something like that no movie is so perfect…… But genuinely saying this movie is really worth watching in theatre.... I should say a must watch movie... |
|
|
| Aravind 3 Nov 09, 06:29am |
Richard...Sorry to say your review is really pathetic.
1)Tamil or any other regional movies cant meet Hollywood standards as they cant afford big budget.
2)Movie is based on Russian movie which in turn based on a Novel.
3)There are some flaws in the overall screenplay but this movie is much more better than your PUNCH dialogue craps like Vijay/Ajith/Bharath etc.
4) Try to appreciate things for something they tried differently.
5) Hard work given by the crew is extraordinary for the tamil movie.
overall Its a worth trying once atleast rather than simply criticize |
|
|
| Dinesh 2 Nov 09, 01:59pm |
| Friends, movie is not that much good. I watched yesterday and really disappointing. My option is not to waste your money.. |
|
|
| Sullan 2 Nov 09, 12:22pm |
| enna kodumai saravanan...!!! |
|
|
| Laks 2 Nov 09, 05:55am |
| Different attempt in tamil cinema and the movie is really worth a watch..appreciate entire team's hardwork! |
|
|
| Junaith Ali 1 Nov 09, 02:02pm |
| i love ravi and he roczzzz in this movie |
|
|
| Anil 31 Oct 09, 03:52pm |
I completely agree with Richard's review.
the story and concept is good. but the direction, and screenplay was so bad! So many stupid things! armed villains running away from unarmed girls because they get 'scared' of their 'durga, kali, sakthi' look! and everybody in the commments just keep talking about jayam ravi's rooks and the the girls appearing great! nobody talks any sense about this movie. oh... well... there is nothing called 'sense' in this stupid movie! |
|
|
| Praveen 29 Oct 09, 07:10pm |
this the one of the best movie of 2009 in tamil flim industry
and i like very much jeyam ravi in this flim. ravi roczzzz
|
|
|
| Indian 29 Oct 09, 04:33pm |
| The review is more than perfecet. Movie is so dum it got no logic |
|
|
| Deepak 29 Oct 09, 01:09pm |
hi .this is one of the gud movie in jayam ravi's movie career.i strongly blame richard reviews over peranmai.
|
|
|
| G.ASHOKKUMAR 29 Oct 09, 11:00am |
HI, this film is really very good in tamil film indstry you
says any bad comments means you not a indian ........ |
|
|
| Rangudu 28 Oct 09, 11:42am |
hi. i like this film story . Ravi is smart and step up himself through this film.i think Producer should spent some mre money in climax, Ravi is just running with new guns in climax.Totally Good but not best.. All the best for team..
|
|
|
| Fedrick 27 Oct 09, 05:06pm |
| hi this film is super and then jayamravi is a cute and nice actor i wishing a dirctor janathanan you make next movie is to be succses |
|
|
| Fedrick 27 Oct 09, 04:39pm |
| hi this film is super and then jayamravi is a cute and nice actor i wishing a dirctor janathanan you make next movie is to be succses |
|
|
| Aiyoo Aiyoo 26 Oct 09, 05:10pm |
| stupid movie... |
|
|
| Rahul 26 Oct 09, 11:33am |
| hi .this is one of the gud movie in jayam ravi's movie career.i strongly blammed richard reviews. |
|
|
| Karthika 26 Oct 09, 10:47am |
| hai Ravi good morning Have a nice day. |
|
|
| Karthika 26 Oct 09, 10:44am |
| peranmi very energtic film.Ravi Acting very Will and Five girls are very Active girls. |
|
|
| Baskaran 25 Oct 09, 06:20pm |
| The film is very good. A very good effort from Director & needs appreciation.The fight sequence between Roland Kickinger (what a body !!!) & Jayam Ravi which on any given day will look like a complete misfit, looks very realistic thanks mainly to Jayam Ravi's fantastic FLAB FREE physique. He has trimmed down & looks fat free with absoultely no FLAB in his stomach. Way to go Jayam Ravi |
|
|
| Nithya 25 Oct 09, 04:51am |
Richard, It seems U always used to see hollywood movies, so u are expecting this movie to be in that level......atleast u could have given okay feedback...
I liked that movie very much..it was very interesting,,jayam ravi was awesome.....but i did nt like that climax that much... i could have been better....
Jayam Ravi Rockx :-) |
|
|
| Prakash 24 Oct 09, 09:46pm |
| good movie should appreciate..peranmai is milestone 4 tamil |
|
|
| Rv 24 Oct 09, 04:55am |
| Padam kuppayo kuppa... oru scene kooda paarka mudiyala...thaangalada saami... |
|
|
| Indian: 24 Oct 09, 12:25am |
| Its a grt movie . Need to appreicate the director for taking the first step to reach closer in competition to hollywood movies ( just the first step).Still kudos to spj .Jayam Ravi lives the character . |
|
|
| Makesh 23 Oct 09, 07:32pm |
Richard, i cant understand what ur taste is.... the movie really roczzz, every fan coming out of the theatre is completely satisfied.. for the first time a tamil movie ve reached excellent standards.. u ve not mentioned a thing.. hero will never go before those enemies and attack them as u say, he will always try to hide and attack them, to stop their next movements.. he will kill them one by one only, the movie will go in a step by step manner after second half,, which makes it highly intresting... in the climax also he will hide and attack only.. he will never go in front of him.. after all when roland realises that he will never come before him to fight, then he will just start running towards missile. in that time only hero will kill him.. i think u just heared the story from some of ur friends and written this review, or u may ve forgot ur glasses before going to theatre or u should ve seen it in thirutu vcd.. so just see it in a right manner in a theatre and then write the review...
the real VERDICT : THIS TAMIL MOVIE REALLY ROCKZZZZZZZZ... |
|
|
| Chandran 23 Oct 09, 10:55am |
| nice movie..really worth a watch...after the movie was over, forest locations were still going around in front of my eyes..nice cinemotography..on the whole salute to Peranmai team!! |
|
|
| Junaith Ali 23 Oct 09, 10:51am |
| superb movie ravi is not the remake star he is one of the rising star he prove it in this movie............ |
|
|
| Alan 22 Oct 09, 11:23pm |
| really fantastic movie .............it is 1000 times better than (adhavan,atm, kuruvi, villu,kanda samy)(mokkais).........reading this stupid review is waste of time......excellent locations........tribal peoples conditions r very realistic.........ravi's gutz to act in half nude scene should be appreciated.......director's efforts must be enccouraged......camera man is next hero of the film really superb .......worth 2 watch....... |
|
|
| Harini 22 Oct 09, 07:04pm |
| Yes Reallllllllllllly a good movie |
|
|
| Ramesh TEC 22 Oct 09, 01:08pm |
| very good film......every indians should watch this movie....... |
|
|
| GIRISH 22 Oct 09, 07:07am |
NO COMMENTS
|
|
|
| Bharathi Kannan(CSE 2nd YEAR) 22 Oct 09, 01:28am |
| Very good movie!!! I wish to say good luck the entire peranmai team for their hard work.. |
|
|
| Ravin 21 Oct 09, 12:59pm |
| the film is nice |
|
|
| Jeeva 21 Oct 09, 11:45am |
| this movie is perfect copy of chakde india and arjun's jaihind.But good attempt. |
|
|
| Karthic 21 Oct 09, 03:49am |
| Peranmai is 1000 times better comparing with Aadhavan. Without Vadivel Aadhavan is nothing. But movies released just before diwali like Unnai Pol Oruvan, Thiru Thiru Thuru Thuru and Eeram were really rocking and much better than these 2 diwali flicks. I expect more on peranmai. I have to say that, it disappoints me a little. It might be because of my over expectation. But i have to say that the film is not a perfect one to satisfy myself. |
|
|
| Karthic 21 Oct 09, 03:17am |
| This movie is a perfect combination of Chakde India(Hindi) and Mel Gibbson's Apocalypto(Other language) movie. So this movie is good. But originals are the best. |
|
|
| Ravi 20 Oct 09, 11:15pm |
| Very good movie!!! I wish to congratulate the entire peranmai team for their hard work.. And Special Thanks to Mr. Jananadhan...Such a great message... |
|
|
| Rajin 20 Oct 09, 10:44pm |
| goood movie for ur pockets that wont shrink....watch it if u really want to watch something unusual...movies like this should be watched...best movie of our times...jayam ravi has performed..commendable...very good dailogue delivery....admirable...director's treat to this diwali.......very nice |
|
|
| God 20 Oct 09, 02:33pm |
| Very good movie. Very bad review by richard. Reviewer may be Commercial movie fan. Richard may be not aware of The NCC. The NCC cadets are well trained with weapons like Machine gun Another thing is Crocodile is more powerful than an elephant when it is in water. So Duruvan(from childhood, he has been living in the forest) can beat Roland Kickinger. The movie must be watched by young girls. The director added some commercial elements to this movie for the peoples like Richard Mahesh. If this movie is taken in Hollywood, People like Richard will tell the movie is very good. If we encourage this movie, the director definitely will make the movie without commercial elements. If we dont, the director may jump to commercial cinema. |
|
|
| Charan 20 Oct 09, 02:03am |
nice body built by Jayam ravi(except have to improve upon his dialogue delivery),Great direction(some pitfalls here and there), sharp dialogues, excellent cinemotography,crisp editing and so the final product comes out to be 'very good'.
I read some of the negative comments abt this movie but you cant count on any movie to be 100% perfect. i think this is the first movie in Indian cinema taken almost 70% in the forest locations. and i've read the interview from the director how difficult it was while shooting in the forest. We should appreciate this kind of movies and the director for coming up with fresh never told story in tamil cinema. I wish to congratulate the entire peranmai team for their hard work.. |
|
|
| Hakkim 20 Oct 09, 12:09am |
| Nice movie..man you should watch this movie atleat for the second half..what a speed and neat picturaization of the forest locations..simply mind blowing!! go for it!!! congrats peranmai team for this worthy effort! |
|
|
| Kguru1979 19 Oct 09, 09:14pm |
| It is really an excellent movie to watch and far better than aadhavan and jagan mohini ... Kudos to Ravi and Jananadhan...! |
|
|
| Varadharaj 19 Oct 09, 08:14pm |
| it is interesting .... ravi has done very excellent job.... the locations are another hero.... wonderful film with national patriotism..... and also this film is a catalyst for tribal people....... i will give 75 marks out of hundred for this movie |
|
|
| Jalal 19 Oct 09, 07:52pm |
| it is one of the best movies in aathavan .this movie is conformed national award brought to athouor movies |
|
|
| SSR 19 Oct 09, 07:50pm |
I saw பேராண்மை movie today. its an excellent and interesting movie in tamil industry in the recent times.
I am sure this movie will will attract the world cinema including hollywood industry. excellent hard work by jeyam ravi. hats off to the director jananathan and the whole team. jananathan is a great architect of this movie.
THANK YOU DIRECTOR FOR GIVING SUCH AN AMAZING MOVIE!!!
EVERY INDIAN SHOULD WATCH THIS MOVIE. EVERY TAMILAN SHOULD HAVE TO WATCH THIS MOVIE! |
|
|
| Jalal 19 Oct 09, 07:48pm |
| it is the best movie in deepawali |
|
|
| Murugan.N 19 Oct 09, 06:16pm |
| It's very good movie. Dont say Higly disappointing like that. |
|
|
| Sumathi 19 Oct 09, 04:36pm |
| This is a must watch movie. Very decent attempt! |
|
|
| Leela 19 Oct 09, 04:07pm |
| I fully oppose this review. If dhanush beet the villain that is highly disappointing Villain is also a human being not down to earth. Ravi is apt for this. If the same story come in Holliwood people appriciate that but in Koliwood. This is the draw back of the koliwood. |
|
|
| Rajesh 19 Oct 09, 03:22pm |
| A fantastic movie....each Indian should go and watch the movie...really disappointed on seeing the review given here...Hats off to ravi and Jaganathan fortaking such a Standard subject as a story...really worth for money..go and watch... |
|
|
| Charu 19 Oct 09, 02:50pm |
| I diverge this review. |
|
|
| Latha 19 Oct 09, 02:48pm |
| Please don't disappoint the Dirctor and Ravi. Everybody should appriciate them. Nowadays the movies all masala. It's Different one. I think about the certain audiences because they like only super hero who catch the train by bullet cart, or they chacing the helicopter by a horse etc., etc, all of them masala heros. they don't like this type of mivie. Ravi and Jananathan done a good job. |
|
|
| Anonymous 19 Oct 09, 02:21pm |
On the way into the theater, when I watched the poster, I thought may be this is a film by some new actor (so different getup), though I had been told that this was acted by Jeyam Ravi, and all the military getup and unrecognized faces of the actresses, I felt it was going to be a waste of 21/2 hours of time, and my idea was supported by almost the first half of the film, where women were so openly arrogant, and everybody was supporting their arrogance for whatever reason, but after the camping in the woods, it was as if I was reading a thriller book, which could not be kept down, I did not even go for a break, its okay there were some mistakes, but the overall effect was spellbounding, except they could have used a less menacing-looking villain for it to look more real and believable and could have controlled the tongues of those girls, and the easygoing reaction to it by Jeyam Ravi for all the tonguelashing against him (he could have given them back a little, only a saint can keep quiet like that).
|
|
|
| Bala 19 Oct 09, 11:10am |
| realy a super movie. present days masala movies only mokkai movies . this kind of movies really a fantastic one. l like duruvan character. must watch it. 75/100 |
|
|
| Anish 19 Oct 09, 10:16am |
| The movie would have been far better if there is no scenes like the one where the ranger kicks the tribal ppl or the place where the gals make over themselves like..kali..durgai...which gives a same old masala touch to the fast running screen play... |
|
|
| Thilak 19 Oct 09, 09:59am |
| excellent movie..a must watch movie..i know it is not a regular agmark commercial entertainer. but a new brave attempt in tamil cinema. i can see entire team's hardwork in each and every frame..especially cinemotographer satishkumar. my wishes to Jananathan and entire crew. I would prefer Peraanmai over Aadhavan. |
|
|
| Harish 19 Oct 09, 07:47am |
| Peranmai is a stupid, foolish and utter waste of time and money. I don't know y directors take people for granted nowadays...i am not sure if the director has lost track of his original script or is this the original script...some trained terrorists with heavy armed equipments being chased by some NCC trainee girls.....Bullshit....lol...ravi talks too much in this movie......the film was indirectly boasting about the directors knowledge and research done on military equipments and forest trekking....i was a serious movie, but i was laughing throughout......it was like a comedy movie....this movie is a total waste of time and one can do something better in this 2.5 hrs........this is one of the worst movies i have ever seen in my life....i am worried that tamil cinema is going backwards day by day.... |
|
|
| Ashwath Mani 19 Oct 09, 06:02am |
| The review was extremely honest and an apt summary of what the movie was about and could have been. But Mr. Richard Mahesh should think twice before giving a movie such as 'Peranmai' a 'highly disappointing' rating. The movie was a honest and brave attempt on the part of director Janardhanan to give all diwali movie goers- who are usually subject to crass and frankly horrible movies such as Kurivi, Villu, ETC ETC, a different slice of cinema altogether! I'm sure the budget would not have been much to start with, but the team of Peraanmai have used there resources well. Hats off to the team for giving all tamil movie fans something to think about rather than mindless comedy, insane punch dialogues and item numbers. Hats off to Jayam Ravi for his excellent portrayal of a Forest Ranger. The girls were quite frankly the bane of the movie. They could have done better. |
|
|
| John 19 Oct 09, 01:59am |
| s.p.jananathan tries to do films like speilberg. but kollywood is his major bar. |
|
|
| Leo 19 Oct 09, 01:56am |
read ur comment richard. its ingeunine. s.p.jananathan is making a kollywood movie..not a hollywood film. he has lot of restrictions here from that film production. just for marketing sake he has used Oorvasi, Vadivelu, Ponvannan and even Roland Kickinger. no other reason. thats forgivable in tamil cinema. even though jayam ravi tried to be masculine/brave in his figures his voice spoiles his role and even though he justified his role in his acting, this film's main problem is choosing him as the male lead. i personally felt the plot mainly focuses on caste issue than country issue. in such case director should have chosen vishal. jayam ravi looks fair/classy rather a slum guy/ low-caste guy. audience cant relate ravi with that caste people.
vishal would perfectly look like a scheduled caste/well-built/much braver than ravi/atleast a reasonable person to fight against Roland Kickinger. the climax would have been much more emotional. the so called B and C audience would have related him with them and would got some message atleast. |
|
|
| Sankar 19 Oct 09, 12:10am |
| Super Movie!!! Director, Ravi, Photography, Vidyasagar and the girls are rocking... worth to watch it.. |
|
|
| Siva. 18 Oct 09, 10:58pm |
| I am big fan of jayam ravi next to Surya.I have watched the movie on first day first show.Its really superb film and Ravi looks really nice.His Action also good.A must watch film for everyone.Dont miss it.......After the flop of Dham Dhoom Jayam Ravi really rocked in Peranmai...All the very best to Jayam ravi and his team for the upcoming moviezzzzzzz..... |
|
|
| Velmurugan 18 Oct 09, 07:46pm |
| He brought hollywood style cineme to tamil.... great movie by jananathan.. milsestone for ravi |
|
|
| Vel 18 Oct 09, 07:45pm |
| It's an excellent movie. Hats Off to jananathan |
|
|
| Ganesh 18 Oct 09, 07:41pm |
| really peranmai, a must watch movie n da theatre... dere may b slight logicless things.. it's k. v ve to welcome dese movies... ds yr nxt to YAVARUM NALAM anothr hi quality film.... dont miss it |
|
|
| Arun 18 Oct 09, 07:38pm |
| I saw the movie.. Its just superb.. A must watch movie |
|
|
| Karthik 18 Oct 09, 07:04pm |
| if we didnt encourage this types of movies then there will be the coming of movies like KURUVI,AALVAR,AZHAGAR MALAI,MADURAI SAMBAVAM etc., this film can be surely compared to HOLLYWOOD and KAMAL movies.excellent movie....the one who dislikes the film surely they would be the watcher of the movies which i told bfore |
|
|
| Ragu 18 Oct 09, 05:32pm |
| watch peranmai is good to feel |
|
|
| Mahesh 18 Oct 09, 03:58pm |
| stupid review. Wasting time of reading richard review. |
|
|
| Tamilan 18 Oct 09, 03:57pm |
| You stupid richard mahesh....Do you know tamil. Watch the movie once again. |
|
|
| Karthik 18 Oct 09, 11:49am |
Worth of watching! Full credit goes to director for his script!! I had got feel of watching an maniratnam movie!!
director rocks as well as ravi! |
|
|
| Kp.Thamilarasan 18 Oct 09, 09:50am |
| First Tamil Hollywood Movie |
|
|
| Druvan 18 Oct 09, 06:48am |
| mile stone for ravi......he s on d gr8 move |
|
|
| Druvan 18 Oct 09, 06:47am |
| aadhavan == kuruvi-part2 |
|
|
| Rajiv 18 Oct 09, 02:17am |
| To tell the truth, i saw both Aadhavan and Peranmai, and i liked Peranmai much better. Disappointing movie by suriya, no story, no logic. Aadhavan 2/5 and peranmai 3.5/5 |
|
|
| Ramar 18 Oct 09, 12:04am |
I don't know how much time do you expect the fight sequence continue.. Its cinema. not a real life..
Karnan is great archer, have you seen Karna film, how much time will it take to kill Sivaji in that.. Its cienma, you have to take the impact of the fight or something in the shot.
We SHOULD appreciate the director for a new theme to Tamil Cinema and appreciate the Ravi for his hard work. |
|
|
| Rajan 17 Oct 09, 10:53pm |
| Watch Peranmai.. Superb |
|
|
| Sunil 17 Oct 09, 10:23pm |
| padam katu mokka......rendu mani neram waste....plus enga appa kasu 150 ruba erinju pochu nu nenachikiren.....idhuku mit la sunil nu oru naai edukura class eh gavanikalam pola...... |
|
|
| Sarat 17 Oct 09, 10:22pm |
| hi i jus watched peranmai,gud movie guys.different story n throughout the movie ravi rocks wid is metallic looks.havnt seen aadhavan et but heard frm my frens its again a old story-re polished.let me watch the movie |
|
|
| Junaith Ali 17 Oct 09, 09:15pm |
| peranmai roczzzzzzzzzzzzzz |
|
|
| Prabhu 17 Oct 09, 08:27pm |
| its a awesome movie...really worth watchin... folks check out tis film in theatre..... |
|
|
| Kumar 17 Oct 09, 04:53pm |
| peraanmai is hit |
|
|
| Kumar 17 Oct 09, 04:52pm |
| peraanmai is superb and it will definitely beat aadhavan |
|
|
| A,V.Karthik 17 Oct 09, 04:39pm |
| The movie is very nice. |
|
|
| Ram 17 Oct 09, 04:19pm |
jayam ravi rocks
hats of 2 him gr8 job
sure dis movie ll taking a tamil cinema on next stage |
|
|
| Daredevildaddy 17 Oct 09, 03:11pm |
| aadavan is really rocking ........chance less surya is fabu...totally aadavan gonna move out of the theater in a week tats for sure.....put ur money even in the manhole don waste it by getting in to the theater .....persons suffering frm cardio disease pls don take the risk bye |
|
|
| Hameed 17 Oct 09, 02:12pm |
No, Richards review is bad, comparing the off late movies, this one is sure hit..
I really like the way the movie unveils
If not a mega hit, the movie surely will be superhit. |
|
|
| Sree 17 Oct 09, 01:22pm |
| i think this movie is going 2b a big block buster it reveals the other side of ravi's capability best of luck 2 ravi |
|
|
| Sudharshana And Shruthi 17 Oct 09, 01:09pm |
| peranmai is also good like aadhavan.ravi is very smart. wish u all the best.there is excellent thrill. music AND dialog are superb.8.5/10 |
|
|
| Sudharshana And Shruthi 17 Oct 09, 12:58pm |
| peranmai is also good like aadhavan. |
|
|
| Kaari 17 Oct 09, 10:42am |
This is an excellent attempt - all have done their best.
Music, photography, dialog, etc are good.
My suggestions: I notice three themes in this movie -
1. A low cast person being ill treated by others;
2. Four girls taken to a jungle for training;
3. International mercenareies trying to destroy an Indian
satellite.
The director should have focused on one theme.
Action scenes are often somewhat loosely done - it should
be very "sharp" and precise. Jayam Ravi must improve his dialog delivery technique. He has done well otherwise.
Overall: 6.5/10
- Kaari.
|
|
|
| RAJA 17 Oct 09, 09:37am |
| TRULY IF IM SAYING PERANMAI 100 TIMES BETTER THAN mokkai AADAVAN :d |
|
|
| Coolriddler 17 Oct 09, 09:00am |
A Total waste of time, i really appreciate the director's idea of showing discrimination and etc etc.. but he made a mess with something to do with the grey matter, im talking about logic.
A group of 16 trained assasins, being scared of some random people is too much.
i really dont understand which forest guard knows all about latest missiles.
the climax was utter rubbish. logic was no where around.
i guess an army person who specializes in armoury and weapons himself wont be able to figure out missiles.
You saw how they play with such a higg tech gadget, "press stop button", "press down arrow" god i dont event wanna think about it. |
|
|
| ANS 17 Oct 09, 01:45am |
| Spot on richard!!! dreadful movie.....jananathan has disappointed us...hes a good director...hope he comes out with a good film soon!!! not worth watching in theaters .... i really wonder how they convinced Kickinger to act in this film!!! |
|
|
| Karthic 17 Oct 09, 01:23am |
| SP Jananathan is the only one who has good thinking capability among tamil cinema directors. |
|
|
| Rocko 17 Oct 09, 01:03am |
| Hi guys.....ur review is a lot perplexin as I watched first day first show.As some of dem hd said u cn accept a formula derived for Vijay or some crap...nd cant appreciate films lik dis.Even in Rocky Stallone bashes bad guys who are hefty than hm.Come on Man appreciate such ventures....I say its a MUST WATCH in THEATRES!!!!!Ravi rocs.... |
|
|
| Bharat 17 Oct 09, 12:34am |
| When making a movie, intentions alone cannot be rewarded. when you are ready to take all Laddus after Iyarkai and "E", Jannanathan is due for some L@v@d@. Social discrimination, poverty, Tribal people's plight all these can be said in different movies one by one. he wants to show he is a communist, wants to show off his prowess for research.. all this would have been good if the screenplay and all the initial stupidity of 5 girls going to great lengths against Jayam Ravi had been avoided. more thinking into action sequences. Movie is crap. watched it for the reasonable respect which i had for jananathan but he has slipped down into the abyss. period. |
|
|
| Abbas 16 Oct 09, 11:28pm |
Film is Nice.. Hearty Congrats to janathan & jayam Ravi..
Is Society doesnt allow him to Tell Story without Commercial Mixing.. Whose Mistake is this..???
Director's..? OR people's taste..???
Anyway Nice.. |
|
|
| Prasad 16 Oct 09, 10:58pm |
I went to watch Peranmai with great expectations and it did fulfill in all aspects.
No big heroines, commercial masala elements makes the film more interesting and pacey.
Jayam Ravi has done an excellent role and lived the character throughout the movie.
Vadively, Orvasi, Ponvannan on right proportions.
Great Cinematography and real spellbound Forest locations.
Ronald is a real Macho and action sequences are choreographed nicely....
Verdict: *****
A must watch........
And a five star to the Jagannath & Jayam Ravi
|
|
|
| Dinesh 16 Oct 09, 10:32pm |
| this flim is 1000 times better than a comartial fools films. They r just flying and fighting and just a sexy kuttu dance. They dnt know nothing than this. Peranmai realy rocks. |
|
|
| Leslie 16 Oct 09, 09:55pm |
| huh! come on.. u guys can watch vijay bumpin off 20 ppl in a go and u cant digest this?. and this s not something new to tamil cinema... accepted tat some stunt sequences wer over the board , but tat apart, the movie s definitely a feather in Jananathan's cap. Ravi was excellent, Roland Kickinger was wasted... expected a lot frm him... and the social messages are bang on target. A different genre explored in Tamil cinema. camera ia fantastic. Music cud hav helped more, Thr r some loopholes, but overall the movie s definitely worth watching. |
|
|
| Gopu 16 Oct 09, 09:18pm |
| i am dissappointed with ur review..these kind of film rare 2 see..its a good patriotic and action packed film..all guys watch the film..dont miss it.see in theatres... |
|
|
| Venkat 16 Oct 09, 09:06pm |
| its a different movie .. compared to all movies. pl go and watch in theartes |
|
|
| Kumar 16 Oct 09, 08:39pm |
| Flim is good, pls watch the movie in theatre. |
|
|
| Senthil 16 Oct 09, 07:56pm |
Guys.. pls watch in theartes.... encourge the great attempt by Jananathan...
Up & downs are there... but when it come to fantasy cinema.... we should avoid the minor things & welcome this great great attempt.... |
|
|
| Harsha 16 Oct 09, 06:38pm |
stupid review!!!!!!!!!
peranmai is a very gud movie .itz a must watch.
ravi has showcased is acting skills in a big way.
the whole unit must hav workd hard 2 giv dis kind of film.
the director rocks!!!!oly drawback of d movie is ders less scope 4 vadivelu n music shud hav been better. |
|
|
| Jijo1 16 Oct 09, 06:29pm |
| Yes...I go with the comments of Senthil. No one touched the line like this developed/developing countries not like our develope in anything. And see, how the director researces about the guns, politics....Richard, please go and watch the movie once again for the dialogues (Ravi and the tribal origin (the handy person who speaks when the forest officials kicking them) and also the gals who dont know about the poverty/poor India). But at the same time i do agree that Roland's char could have been done better. Dont blame the muzic and comedy (without songs or comedy, our people will not accept except Kamal's movie)...So just leave this part but i think the back ground score is OK. And see, in the climax..the higher authority guy only getting reward/award where he done nothing. Its true. I can say many examples like this.. So finally, its a good movie to watch. We should welcome movies like this. |
|
|
| ABK 16 Oct 09, 06:16pm |
This review is totally correct!! This movie is total crap!!
Maybe the next movie will see Jayam ravi beating off Arnold Schwarzenegger in less than 20 seconds! LOL! |
|
|
| Senthil 16 Oct 09, 05:33pm |
I disagree with ur review.....
May b ur expectation has been not reached...
This is one of the never made adventours movie.... Social discrimination has been clearly presented//// Jayam ravi has done justice to his role... he was training every thing to the girls... bcoz he is just a trainer & he has limitation since he game from tribal family. climax cleary shows the limitations |
|